doppelmayr vs poma
Peter
27 Apr 2008
D-CTEC lifts have parts from both, however St. Jerome makes the detachable terminals. Salt Lake City makes chairs, line equipment, and fixed grip terminals.
SkiLift101
27 Apr 2008
i dont really know all the technical stuff, but i prefer the look of the dopps over the pomas.
bushmogulmaster
27 Apr 2008
SkiLift101
28 Apr 2008
bushmogulmaster
28 Apr 2008
SkiLift101, on Apr 28 2008, 12:14 PM, said:
do you have any pics?
Yeah. Let me dig back through the "archives" of pictures, and I'll try to post a pic or two for you.
Little "teaser" pic of the mechanism/terminal design:

New LPA grip (there are two grips on the rail, one in the foreground, and a smaller version in the background):
Guest_mjturley34_* 28 Apr 2008
Nice pics do you have anymore close ups of that guy's back ? Maybe his shoe against the term skin ? Any better angles of the grip ? Don't mean to be picky but if the new stuff is better it would nice see why/how
bushmogulmaster
28 Apr 2008
mjturley34, on Apr 28 2008, 02:46 PM, said:
Nice pics do you have anymore close ups of that guy's back ? Maybe his shoe against the term skin ? Any better angles of the grip ? Don't mean to be picky but if the new stuff is better it would nice see why/how
I'll see what I can put together. I might have a few different angles of the grip. That "guy" is Tom Clink, our tour guide. He's the sales manager, but spent years running the lift department at Breck. Knows his stuff about lifts.
I don't really think that the new LPA grip is "better," per se. It's just different. I guess the Italians (I believe Leitner wanted this new design, IIRC) don't like ball joints, so they didn't like the eccentric spring packs of the Omega grip. L-POA wants to use the Omega grip as long as possible. Not sure how soon we'll see the new grip on US installations.
This is really all I have:
Whole "demo" unit:

LPA grip jaw:

LPA grip from the other side (good look at the traction plate):
This post has been edited by skiersage: 29 April 2008 - 08:02 AM
Peter
28 Apr 2008
Do you have any idea when that new terminal design will be seen in new installations?
bushmogulmaster
28 Apr 2008
Skier, on Apr 28 2008, 05:07 PM, said:
Do you have any idea when that new terminal design will be seen in new installations?
The impression I got was that it will be soon. But I don't really know how soon. The ones they were constructing the two times I was at the factory were Omegas. Maybe next summer's installs?
SkiLift101, on Apr 28 2008, 06:01 PM, said:
thanks for the pics! did you take those?
Yep. Fun place to visit.
Snoqualmie guy
30 Apr 2008
For the Dopp-CTEC lifts, what decides if it has CTEC style chairs or Dopp.?
Peter
30 Apr 2008
I think the customer still has a choice between the Doppelmayr EJ chairs and Garaventa "Vail" chairs. I think they have finally stopped using the old CTEC chairs and the plan at some point was to stop offering the EJ chairs.
Bill
04 May 2008
DonaldMReif
07 Mar 2009
One thing different between the two types of lifts is the towers. Poma towers are always square shaped, but Dopplemayr towers can be either square shaped with extended arms over the ends at the top, or triangular shaped into the tower. Vail uses both of those examples (box for Avanti Express, Born Free Express, and Orient Express and triangles on the Northwoods Express, Mountaintop Express, Vista Bahn Express, and Game Creek Express), as does Beaver Creek (triangular on Centennial Express, box on Arrow Bahn Express). In addition, Poma grips tend to be almost in the same position in the terminal as they are on the line, while Dopplemayr grips tend to have the rollers in a lower position in the terminal.
2milehi
07 Mar 2009
Electronics
Doppelmayr uses a Pilz PLC to monitor everything. With clocked outputs feeding various sensors and monitored outputs, it can be VERY difficult to jump out a fault. Grip force is monitored by a deflection prox that is susceptible to static discharge between the haul rope and the grip.
Poma uses an Allen Bradley PLC to monitor everything. Every normal stop can be jumped out via a touch screen and a "Safeties Bypass" switch. Some E-Stops can be jumped out with a switch, touch screen, and "Safeties Bypass". Grip force is measured by a mechanical switch (Go, No Go).
As long as protocalls are followed, it is TONS easier to jump out faults on a Poma and clear the line if need be.
This post has been edited by 2milehi: 07 March 2009 - 03:28 PM
Doppelmayr uses a Pilz PLC to monitor everything. With clocked outputs feeding various sensors and monitored outputs, it can be VERY difficult to jump out a fault. Grip force is monitored by a deflection prox that is susceptible to static discharge between the haul rope and the grip.
Poma uses an Allen Bradley PLC to monitor everything. Every normal stop can be jumped out via a touch screen and a "Safeties Bypass" switch. Some E-Stops can be jumped out with a switch, touch screen, and "Safeties Bypass". Grip force is measured by a mechanical switch (Go, No Go).
As long as protocalls are followed, it is TONS easier to jump out faults on a Poma and clear the line if need be.
This post has been edited by 2milehi: 07 March 2009 - 03:28 PM
Kicking Horse
07 Mar 2009
2milehi, on Mar 7 2009, 04:22 PM, said:
Electronics
Doppelmayr uses a Pilz PLC to monitor everything. With clocked outputs feeding various sensors and monitored outputs, it can be VERY difficult to jump out a fault. Grip force is monitored by a deflection prox that is susceptible to static discharge between the haul rope and the grip.
Poma uses an Allen Bradley PLC to monitor everything. Every normal stop can be jumped out via a touch screen and a "Safeties Bypass" switch. Some E-Stops can be jumped out with a switch, touch screen, and "Safeties Bypass". Grip force is measured by a mechanical switch (Go, No Go).
As long as protocalls are followed, it is TONS easier to jump out faults on a Poma and clear the line if need be.
Doppelmayr uses a Pilz PLC to monitor everything. With clocked outputs feeding various sensors and monitored outputs, it can be VERY difficult to jump out a fault. Grip force is monitored by a deflection prox that is susceptible to static discharge between the haul rope and the grip.
Poma uses an Allen Bradley PLC to monitor everything. Every normal stop can be jumped out via a touch screen and a "Safeties Bypass" switch. Some E-Stops can be jumped out with a switch, touch screen, and "Safeties Bypass". Grip force is measured by a mechanical switch (Go, No Go).
As long as protocalls are followed, it is TONS easier to jump out faults on a Poma and clear the line if need be.
Poma Safety Bypasses can be a pain IN THE ASS to set a bypass.... ;). Since I have been a Drive Operator on both Poma and Doppelmaryr I'm going to say that I like the Poma's better. @ least the new ones. Have not ran an old Poma yet. But that time is coming in the next few weeks.
skierdude9450
07 Mar 2009
Were all of the pictures of the LPA/Multix system taken in France? I know that it has been used in Europe for four years now, but any word on if we'll ever see it in America?
2milehi
07 Mar 2009
Kicking Horse, on Mar 7 2009, 07:43 PM, said:
Poma Safety Bypasses can be a pain IN THE ASS to set a bypass.... ;). Since I have been a Drive Operator on both Poma and Doppelmaryr I'm going to say that I like the Poma's better. @ least the new ones. Have not ran an old Poma yet. But that time is coming in the next few weeks.
OK Kicking Horse - how is bypassing a Poma Safety Bypasses a pain in the A$$?
DonaldMReif
08 Mar 2009
bushmogulmaster, on Apr 28 2008, 03:56 PM, said:
I'll see what I can put together. I might have a few different angles of the grip. That "guy" is Tom Clink, our tour guide. He's the sales manager, but spent years running the lift department at Breck. Knows his stuff about lifts.
I don't really think that the new LPA grip is "better," per se. It's just different. I guess the Italians (I believe Leitner wanted this new design, IIRC) don't like ball joints, so they didn't like the eccentric spring packs of the Omega grip. L-POA wants to use the Omega grip as long as possible. Not sure how soon we'll see the new grip on US installations.
This is really all I have:
Whole "demo" unit:

LPA grip jaw:

LPA grip from the other side (good look at the traction plate):

I don't really think that the new LPA grip is "better," per se. It's just different. I guess the Italians (I believe Leitner wanted this new design, IIRC) don't like ball joints, so they didn't like the eccentric spring packs of the Omega grip. L-POA wants to use the Omega grip as long as possible. Not sure how soon we'll see the new grip on US installations.
This is really all I have:
Whole "demo" unit:

LPA grip jaw:

LPA grip from the other side (good look at the traction plate):

Weren't these grips supposed to come into the U.S.A in 2007? The thread in the images forum for the Highline Express and Sourdough Express lifts at Vail says those two lifts were supposed to use this grip but for some reason got the classic T-Grip they've been cranking for ten years.

